Holiday PartyThu, Dec 10Get tickets
All posts
Guest Speaker

Before the Doors Open: Open House Ethics

TCMC Board8 min read

Thursday, November 12, 2026

The morning, developing

45 photos · 9 moments, developing a few at a time

Moment 5 of 9 · Set 1 of 2

Doreen Roberts

Open house ethics: protecting the seller, one scenario at a time.

9:31 AM3 photosScott Capen and Harv Balu

1 of 3

Photographs by Harv Balu and Scott Capen. Each photo names who took it.

An open house lets strangers walk through your seller's home, and the Code of Ethics walks in with them. At our November 12 meeting, Doreen Roberts took the room through what that means in practice: Article 1's promise to protect the client's interests, one open house scenario at a time.

Why this talk

The question came from one of us. A member asked something their broker couldn't settle, Susan Munkner asked Melrose Forde, and Melrose said to bring in Doreen. It also picks up where Chief Jared Rinetti's open house safety talk left off in October, which raised questions about ethics of its own.

Susan introduced Doreen as a past president of her local association of REALTORS® (2012), its REALTOR® of the Year in 2013, and a certified National Association of REALTORS® Code of Ethics instructor who has served on professional standards committees at the local, state and national level. Mostly retired from selling, she still volunteers in professional standards and works as an expert witness. She is also, it came out afterward, an Irvington High graduate.

Her checklist

Walk it first. Especially when you hold someone else's listing, walk the house before the doors open: uneven steps, loose rugs, weak decks, dim stairwells, exposed nails or wires. Tape off anything unsafe, and keep caution tape in your trunk, because people ignore signs. An unfenced pool needs a person posted at the door to it, and a word to every family with small children. Pets leave for the showing.

Protect the seller's privacy. Medications, valuables and personal papers leave the house entirely, not for a drawer that visitors will open. Every phone is a scanner, and a net sheet left on the counter tells a buyer what the seller hopes to get. The listing agreement already covers this, she noted: the seller keeps the home insured and takes reasonable precautions, knowing visitors may take photos and video.

Cameras, both ways. If the seller records audio or video, post a notice. Tell your own buyers that cameras may be running either way: they hide in phone chargers and teddy bears now. And assume visitors are recording you, so say nothing about the property, the neighbors or the owners you wouldn't want played back.

Make room for everyone. A true story: a seller with new hardwood floors wanted shoes off, and a visiting agent whose shoe was attached to his prosthetic leg was turned away with his clients. The room's fix was shoe covers, kept in your car. Doreen's worry was an ADA complaint landing on the seller. If a visitor says an animal is an assistance animal, let it in; don't ask for papers. Service animals are dogs, she said, and, believe it or not, miniature horses.

Two agents, every time. That has long been her policy, and it was Chief Rinetti's advice too. It isn't only safety: groups split up, a second agent covers the other rooms and the interruptions, and you have a second witness. From her expert witness work, attorneys ask how one agent could have watched a house that size.

When it happens. Someone opens a dresser drawer: that isn't part of the sale, let's move on. Children running loose: be direct with the parents. A buyer wants a contractor under the house: make an appointment for another day. A neighbor says the house is haunted: write it in your AVID, attribute it to the neighbor, and don't dismiss it, because they will tell the next buyer too. In one lawsuit she worked on, a neighbor's story about a long-ago standoff with the county appraiser became part of the case. After the last visitor leaves, secure the house.

From the floor

  • Lock the door, or Article 10? Chief Rinetti said to lock the door if someone approaching makes you uneasy. Judge behavior, Doreen said, never race, religion or any other protected class. Anyone acting unsafely can be asked to leave, and if they won't, call the police. Her own example: a woman with an empty bag who touched everything, so Doreen walked the house beside her.
  • What if another agent hosts it? Liability goes back to the owner in the end, she said, though the agent in between may be pulled in.
  • Do support dogs need a tag? The agent at the door isn't the gatekeeper. The guidance is murky, and a lawsuit costs the seller more.
  • A second pair of hands. Loan officers and title reps will often help staff an open house, a member added. Fine, she said, as long as anyone unlicensed sticks to what's on the property sheet.
  • Who answers for an allergic reaction to the snacks? She had no ruling to point to, so: skip the common allergens. Fresh-squeezed lemonade got a nod.

Watch it

The talk starts about 25 minutes into the recording, with Susan's introduction, and runs through the questions.

The council streamed the meeting on Facebook Live, and the recording is on its YouTube channel. This opens at Susan's introduction and runs through the questions. Press play to watch it right here, pop it out anytime, or watch it on YouTube.

Also on Thursday

First-timer. Scott Roberts of Compass in Walnut Creek found us by asking ChatGPT for marketing meetings in the Fun Cities. He helps seniors move to their next stage of life, and his fun fact: four children, ages 24, 23, 22 and 3.

Sponsors. Stacy Lin of Farmers Insurance talked about indexed annuities with a lifetime income rider as one way to shield retirement savings from a market downturn. Room sponsor Samantha Granado is back: after 14 years in real estate marketing, she now does design, print and promotional products as Call Samantha. Janet Huynh of Flagstar Bank joins as our newest sponsor. And the sponsors' thank-you loop played as everyone came in; Anthony says it will run every morning.

Listings, as presented.

  • Scott Roberts: 6649 Mayhews Landing Rd, Newark, on Super Tour, $1,158,000. Two bedrooms, one and a half baths and 1,167 square feet with 1950s charm, hardwood floors and an updated kitchen, on an 8,486-square-foot lot made for parties. Open that weekend with fresh-baked treats from the garden, and lemonade from the yard's lemons.
  • Dianna Novela: two Fremont rentals. A two-bedroom, two-bath condo at Metro Crossing, 1,285 square feet with a resort-style pool, $4,100 a month; it is for sale now and rents if no offer comes within about two weeks. And two houses on one lot, three bedrooms and one bath each, at $3,050 and $2,700 a month on a six-month lease, before six new homes go up there. Her Hayward listing is still for sale.

Announcements. Adopt-an-Angel still has gift tags, and a wish list for gifts shipped straight to its workshop. Valerie G sells hand-lettered Thanksgiving cards. The Fremont Chamber of Commerce held Breakfast with the Mayor on Friday and holds the city's first business awards gala on February 18, with nominations open. Dianna, 2027 president-elect of Women's Council of REALTORS® Alameda County, invited everyone to Women's Council events; its installation that Friday was sold out. Scott Capen invited everyone to the reception for the Olive Hyde Art Gallery's Youth Emerging Voices show, and has 2027 calendars coming after Thanksgiving. And holiday party tickets are $35: Thursday, December 10, 5 to 8 PM, in Niles.

The drawing. Valerie's two bundles of cards, a mug full of teas (Frank promised a review) and Samantha's surprise bag of chocolate pretzels and a book by a local author all found homes. Bill Can!trell took home $50. And the meeting ended with the whole room singing Happy Birthday to Ingrid.

Coming up: November 19, the C.A.R. directors' update from three past presidents, Steve Medeiros and Melrose Forde among them. No meeting on Thanksgiving, November 26.

Thank you

Thank you to Doreen for a clear, practical hour, to Susan and Melrose for bringing her in, to Steve Medeiros for leading the Pledge, and to the hospitality team, Shufrah, Marlyn, Betty and Ninez, for breakfast.

We meet Thursday mornings from 8:45 in Fremont. Guests are welcome, and the speaker calendar has who is coming next.

Photographs by Harv Balu and Scott Capen, Scott Capen Photography; each photo names who took it. Words by Harv Balu. The meeting was streamed on Facebook Live and posted to the council's YouTube channel.

Sources

  • The meeting: the council's recording of November 12, 2026, on YouTube. The talk starts at 25:12.
  • The Code of Ethics: the National Association of REALTORS® Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice, Articles 1 and 10.
  • Service animals: the U.S. Department of Justice's ADA guide to service animals, which covers dogs and, under a separate rule, miniature horses.
  • The listings: as presented at the meeting. 6649 Mayhews Landing Rd's details match its Super Tour entry and MLS listing 41153393.

Disclosures

  • This post reports what was said at the November 12, 2026 meeting of the Tri-Cities Marketing Council. It is general information, not legal advice. Fair housing, disability access, recording and liability turn on the facts of each case: ask your broker or an attorney.
  • The annuity talk is summarized for the record. It is not financial advice, and the council does not endorse any company or product mentioned.
  • Listing details are as the agents presented them on November 12, and they can change. They are not an offer. Check with the listing agent.
  • Photographs © 2026 Harv Balu and © 2026 Scott Capen Photography, each marked on the photo. Please ask before reusing them.

The conversation

Start the conversation.

Never published, never shared. It lets the council know a real person is behind the comment.

Comments are reviewed by the council before they appear.